Search
Generic filters

Supported by:

19 November 2026

What the Oath-Taking Opinion Really Means

Strict compliance with certain statutory rules, especially those enacted by the ancien régime deliberately to maintain its power even beyond an eventual electoral defeat, may result in the “perpetuation of an unacceptable status quo”, a condition which I had characterized, darkly, as a “Sisyphean democracy”. Nowhere is this condition more visible than in post-2023 Poland. A recent Opinion of the Venice Commission on the presidential oath-taking from newly elected judges of the Constitutional Tribunal illustrates well an approach of principled resistance to “adherence to existing legislation”. I welcome this approach. Continue reading >>
0
16 November 2026
, ,

Poland’s Captured Judiciary and the Challenges of Repair

On 30 October 2026, Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, acting President of Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal, temporarily suspended the two judges hitherto exercising the functions of President and Vice-President. Her actions have generated considerable controversy. In an earlier post, we defended the orders as complying with European and Polish law, and we also defended the lawfully elected judges’ efforts to restore the Constitutional Tribunal’s functioning and status as an independent and impartial tribunal established by law. A critical chorus has attacked her actions. In this post, we counter this chorus of critics. Continue reading >>
0
09 November 2026

MMA Fighters Will Not Restore the Rule of Law

On 30 October 2026, Constitutional Tribunal judge, Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, decided to suspend the President and Vice-President of the Constitutional Tribunal. In a recent post on Verfassungsblog, Kim-Lane Scheppele, Laurent Pech and Maciej Kisilowski praised this move as lawful and necessary to restore the rule of law. In this post I present a different view. I argue that the legality of the order is doubtful and that to truly heal the Tribunal something else is needed – a rebuilding of its legitimacy, credibility and authority. Continue reading >>
0
02 November 2026
, ,

Whose Coup?

The temporary suspension on 30 October 2026 of the two judges who had usurped the leadership of Poland’s unlawfully composed Constitutional Tribunal produced startling images of a police cordon around the court and a chaotic confrontation with the president of the Republic. Radical-right political movements in Poland and abroad quickly portrayed the intervention as a coup d’état. Legally, however, the intervention marked an important – and necessary - step towards restoring the rule of law. Continue reading >>
02 November 2026

The Oath “Towards” the President and the Suspension of the Chief Justice

On Friday, 30 October, amid protests and riots in front of the Constitutional Tribunal, a group of judges elected to it this year by the centrist parliamentary majority entered its premises. One of these judges, Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, suspended the court’s president and vice-president for 30 days for obstructing its work. The escalation follows months of conflict in which Polish President Karol Nawrocki refused to receive the oath of the duly elected new judges, a largely ceremonial act that completes their election. Continue reading >>
0
02 November 2026
, , ,

Statement by Former Presidents of the Constitutional Tribunal on the Crisis in the Constitutional Tribunal

The judges lawfully appointed to the Constitutional Tribunal by the Sejm have taken the necessary steps to restore the functions and status of this constitutional institution, which is essential to the rule of law and the protection of citizens’ rights and freedoms. Continue reading >>
0
31 August 2026

Pangloss in Brussels

When it comes to the Commission’s Annual Rule of Law Report, first launched in 2020, the years go by and they all look the same. In its latest edition published last July, the Commission referred to a “broadly positive trajectory” regarding the rule of law in the EU. The year before, the Commission similarly asserted a “positive reform dynamic” and “positive trajectory” in the EU. This phrasing was virtually identical to the one used in 2024 (“positive reform dynamic”) and 2023 (“positive trend”). These claims and figures do not, however, survive close scrutiny. Continue reading >>
0
29 August 2026

A Tribute to David Dyzenhaus and The War Against Law

David Dyzenhaus’ The War Against Law is the most serious critique yet of the legal right's assault on the rule of law. I have found the book extremely interesting, and I would like to devote the following lines to commending both the work itself and its author. Dyzenhaus, Professor of Law at the University of Toronto and originally from South Africa, is one of the few, if not the only, renowned legal scholars who has consistently devoted himself to developing a harsh and serious critique of “the new legal right”. Continue reading >>
16 July 2026

When Lady Justice Lifts Her Blindfold, Briefly

Justice, one could say, did not take off her blindfold on July 7th – but she did lift it, just a fraction, long enough to check in with political reality. Paris’s court of appeal upheld Marine Le Pen’s conviction for misappropriating public funds, yet softened the 2025 ban on her running for office just enough to keep a presidential bid in 2027 on the table. The guilty verdict stands – it is the sentence that now intrudes less directly into the democratic arena. Continue reading >>
0
15 July 2026

The New Constitutional Amendment and the Removal of the President

On 13 July 2026, the Hungarian Parliament enacted the 17th Amendment to the Hungarian Fundamental Law. In line with the TISZA Party’s election manifesto, the Amendment ends the current President of the Republic’s, Tamás Sulyok’s, term of office. This is undoubtedly an extraordinary measure. Given the President’s apparent partiality and his failure to respond consistently to earlier illiberal constitutional developments, I consider the exceptional and temporary constitutional change to be justified as part of the broader effort to lay the foundations of a renewed constitutional order. Continue reading >>
0
Go to Top