13 May 2021
WEBINAR 3: “Science, Law and Decision-Making”
Bringing together experts representing states who have adopted divergent attitudes to the role of science in law and decision-making, as well as an examination of vaccination policy, equity and individual choice, this panel considers the complex policy choices, rationales and politics which interplay in decision-making during a pandemic. Continue reading >>
0 
WEBINAR 2: “Democracy and Disruption”
How has democracy been impacted by over a year of pandemic response and emergency? How have states ensured the democratic accountability of their actions in response to the global health emergency? What lessons can be learned for now, and for the future? This panel examines democratic practices, and highlights the best – and most concerning – developments. Continue reading >>
0
12 May 2021
Short but Sweet
On 11 May 2021, Bulgaria’s President Rumen Radev issued a decree appointing a caretaker government, which means that the dissolution of the 45th National Assembly is imminent. This National Assembly, which was first convened on 15 April 2021, was rather short-lived, but it paved the way to fairer elections and much needed reforms in the justice system which civil society demands. Continue reading >>
0
Sie haben ihm ein Denkmal gebaut
In der Woche, in der Frankreich des 200. Todestags Napoleon Bonapartes feierlich gedachte, schaffte auch der Deutsche Bundestag erinnerungspolitische Fakten. Ohne Gegenstimmen bewilligte er ein Gesetz zur Errichtung einer Bundeskanzler-Helmut-Kohl-Stiftung. Doch die vordergründige Einmütigkeit des Plenums täuscht. Continue reading >>
0
WEBINAR 1: “Human Rights and the COVID-19 Pandemic”
COVID-19 – and state responses to it - present a threat to human rights unparalleled in the contemporary era. At the same time, human rights offer a universal framework which guides decision-makers, ensures accountability for their actions and omissions, and renders visible the structural inequalities which drives the pandemic’s differential impact on certain communities. Looking forward, this panel discusses how human rights can be used to underpin a just and sustainable post-pandemic recovery. Continue reading >>
0
Webinar Series: Power and the COVID-19 Pandemic
Marking the conclusion of the "Power and the COVID-19 Pandemic" Symposium, this webinar series brings together contributors from around the world to discuss the impact of the pandemic on law and governance, drawing on five transversal themes: human rights; democracy; the rule of law; science and decision-making; and the impact of an extended emergency. Continue reading >>
0
11 May 2021
Judikative versus Exekutive
Der österreichische Bundespräsident tritt am 6. Mai 2021 vor die Presse und verkündet, „dass etwas eingetreten ist, das es in dieser Form noch nicht gegeben hat“. Sollte wider Erwarten ein Untersuchungsausschuss des österreichischen Parlaments nicht die vollständigen ihm zugesprochenen Informationen bekommen, „werde er seinen verfassungsmäßigen Pflichten entsprechen“ und das verfassungsgerichtliche Urteil exekutieren. Wie konnte es so weit kommen? Continue reading >>Trump’s Indefinite Ban
After months of waiting, the Facebook Oversight Board has upheld Facebook’s ban of former President Donald Trump. Beyond the merits, the decision underlines a trend showing how the FOB is applying protections of free speech. The FOB’s increasing reliance on the principle of proportionality and transparency is a paradigmatic example of an ever-growing distance to the First Amendment dogma characterising US constitutionalism and the proximity to the European (digital) constitutional approach. Continue reading >>A Stress Test for Politics: Insights from the Comparative Covid Response Project (CompCoRe) 2020
The CompCoRe study, an ongoing qualitative comparison of policy responses to Covid-19 in sixteen core countries and two affiliates, begun in April 2020, sought to identify and explain patterns of perceived success and failure in managing this multifaceted crisis. [...] As national and international authorities look to futures beyond Covid-19, a lesson emerging from our study is that they should revisit their institutional processes for integrating scientific and political consensus-building. If free citizens are unable to see how expertise is serving the collective good, they will sooner rebel against the experts than give up their independence. Just as a sound mind is said to require a sound body, so the coronavirus has shown that the credibility of public health expertise depends on the health of the body politic. Continue reading >>
0
10 May 2021
The World Turned Upside Down
Gates’ charitable foundation and the World Health Organization launched the app ‘GoGiveOne’ where individuals can donate money to ensure ‘vaccines for everyone, everywhere’. It sounds like an opportunity to respond to the crisis. But individualizing a structural problem prevents any real solution to it. Continue reading >>The ECtHR Steps into the Ring
For the last two years, the fight for safeguarding the principle of the rule of law in Poland has been dominated by the ECJ’s case law. During this, the Strasbourg Court has mostly been sitting in the bleachers. Yet, with its Xero Flor judgment of 7 May, it strapped on its gloves and stepped into the ring. It concluded that the Polish Constitutional Tribunal, in its current composition, cannot be seen as a tribunal established by law. The decision will undoubtedly have major political and legal consequences. Continue reading >>
0
Separation of Powers in Climate Cases
On 29 April 2021, the Bundesverfassungsgericht published its decision that the Federal Climate Change Act of 12 December 2019, establishing national climate targets and annual emission amounts allowed until 2030, violates fundamental rights. Do the judges in such a case undermine separation of powers as a time-honoured achievement of modern constitutional democracies in order to force the political branches to take urgently necessary actions? No. By allocating different functions to the three branches, executive, legislature, and judiciary, separation of powers aims to ensure that the tension between law and majoritarian politics is perpetuated and that neither law nor politics dominates the other. Continue reading >>
0
COVID-19 vaccines: How Structural Factors Can Vitiate Patient Autonomy and Dictate Vaccine Choice
Financial self-interest, fiscal considerations, geopolitics, sovereignty, governance, protectionism, and nationalism are currently dictating COVID-19 vaccine procurement at the macro level. Such structural factors indirectly vitiate autonomy at the grassroots level and run counter to the ideal that individuals should have access to the highest attainable standard of health. Continue reading >>09 May 2021
What Should and What Will Happen After Xero Flor
On 7 May 2021, the European Court of Human Rights issued a judgment in a case concerning irregularities in the personal composition of the Polish Constitutional Tribunal. The ECtHR found a violation of “the right to a tribunal established by law” due to fact that the decision on the discontinuation of the proceedings concerning a constitutional complaint filed by a Polish company was issued by the Constitutional Tribunal with the participation of a person who was unlawfully elected to the position of judge. The said judgment is the first ruling of an international body finding that the irregularities in the functioning of the Polish Constitutional Tribunal violate international law. Continue reading >>
0
08 May 2021
Climate Revolution with Weaknesses
With a real bang, the German Federal Constitutional Court has adjudicated what is probably the most far-reaching decision ever made by a supreme court worldwide on climate protection. This does not preclude the fact that the decision also has considerable weaknesses. Continue reading >>
0
Muddling through Mutation Times or the Return of Federalism in Austria
While the Austrian government´s reactions during the first wave of Covid-19 in spring 2020 are considered to have been successful, disillusionment followed in the fall 2020 with a second wave, for which the government did not seem to have prepared properly. The third period (January to April 2021), on which I will focus in this blog entry, shows a mixed performance of the government. Continue reading >>
0
07 May 2021
Ein Grundrecht auf Generationengerechtigkeit?
Der Klimaschutz-Beschluss des BVerfG hat auch über das Umweltrecht hinaus Bedeutung, etwa für den Rechtschutz der jungen Generation in den Bereichen der sozialen Sicherungssysteme oder der Staatsverschuldung. Sie gibt Anlass, sämtliche Säulen des gesellschaftlichen Lebens, bei denen Entscheidungen der Gegenwart zu Lasten für künftige Generationen führen, auf mögliche Beschränkungen intertemporaler Freiheiten abzuklopfen. Continue reading >>The Price of Limiting Power
On 18 April 2021, Mongolia’s political landscape was hit by an unexpected event: President Battulga Khaltmaa issued an official decree in which he suggested to dissolve Mongolia’s 100-year-old ruling party, the Mongolian People’s Party (MPP). What appears to be a political problem at first glance, points to a deeper crisis of Mongolia’s constitutional democracy. Continue reading >>
0
A Failed State in the Making
On 4 May 2021, the Senate house in Zimbabwe approved the Constitutional Amendment No.2, 2019 with a two-thirds majority. The bill is now on its way to the executive for signature and incorporation into the constitution. However, the bill features three concerning clauses linked to judicial independence and the prosecutor general's appointment. The future of democracy and the rule of law looks gloomy for Zimbabwe. Continue reading >>
0
Soziale Netzwerke in der Grundrechts-Klemme?
Seit 2018 häufen sich Klagen, mit denen sich Nutzer dagegen wehren, dass ihre Beiträge auf sozialen Netzwerken wie Facebook gelöscht werden. Gegenteilig will die Grünen-Politikerin Renate Künast nun vor der Richterbank Facebook dazu zwingen, konsequent(er) gegen Falschmeldungen vorzugehen. Netzwerkbetreiber drohen so in eine Klemme zwischen Meinungsfreiheit und Persönlichkeitsschutz zu geraten. Continue reading >>
0
A Government (Un)Governed?
On 16 December 2020, despite rising rates of infection and the widely predicted ‘second wave’ already impacting neighbouring European countries, Prime Minister Boris Johnson mocked the opposition for wanting to ‘cancel Christmas’ by reintroducing nationwide lockdown restrictions. Three days later, a nationwide lockdown in England was introduced (inadvertently mimicking the March 2020 commitment that London had ‘zero prospect’ of lockdown, four days before it was enforced). The lockdown – closing schools, universities and a majority of businesses which were deemed non-essential and prohibiting gatherings of more than two people outdoors from separate households – continued until 12 April 2021 when restrictions began to be lessened through a phased ‘roadmap out of lockdown’. Such political hyperbole by the executive and lax response, followed by sudden U-turn policy making (‘essay crisis’ governance) and severely restrictive measures, have characterised much of the response to the pandemic in the UK. Continue reading >>
0
06 May 2021
The Use of Emergency Powers in Response to COVID-19 in The Gambia
More than a year after the pandemic was first reported in The Gambia, the state is returning to ordinary processes. Many COVID-related restrictions have been lifted, allowing businesses, markets, schools, restaurants, bars, gyms, cinemas, and nightclubs to resume normal operations, and borders to be open. However, from 8 March 2021, police permits will no longer be issued for music festivals, political events, and other forms of social gatherings. This comes against the backdrop of the country’s limited resources, weak healthcare systems, and ineffective mitigating measures including social distancing, self-isolation, and avoiding public gatherings to prevent further spread of the virus. Continue reading >>
0
05 May 2021
Possibly Constitutional, But Not This Way
Earlier this year, the Parliament of the Autonomous Community of Galicia, Spain, amended the regional Health Act of Galicia to introduce, inter alia, the possibility to impose administrative fines on people who ‘unjustifiably refuse’ to comply with an order to be vaccinated against a given disease. This is the first-ever explicit legislative provision in Spain setting out sanctions for those opposing vaccination. On 21 April, the Spanish Constitutional Tribunal declared an unconstitutionality appeal against the reform of the HAG admissible. Continue reading >>
0
Klimaschutz aus Karlsruhe
Das Bundesverfassungsgericht fordert in seinem historischen Klima-Beschluss, über 2031 hinaus zu definieren, wie Emissionen zu reduzieren sind. Die Pointe dieser Konstruktion liegt darin, dass der Gesetzgeber hier nicht nur punktuelle Änderungen für den Zeitraum ab 2031 vornehmen kann, ohne mit anderen Vorgaben Karlsruhes in Konflikt zu geraten. Continue reading >>COVID-19 and Emergency Powers in Western European Democracies: Trends and Issues
Domestic emergency powers resorted to in the Covid-19 crisis are very different from each other. Is it possible to identify common trends in the comparative scenario? Limiting the scope of the analysis to democratic countries of the Western European area, at least four different tendencies can be identified. Continue reading >>04 May 2021
Keine Schutzpflicht vor zukünftigen Freiheitsbeschränkungen – warum eigentlich?
Das Bundesverfassungsgericht stellt in seinem Beschluss vom 24.03.2021 die Verpflichtung für den Gesetzgeber auf, auch für nach 2030 Emissionsziele festzuschreiben. Insoweit das Bundes-Klimaschutzgesetz (KSG) dieses nicht schon heute tut, ist es verfassungswidrig. Dass Karlsruhe hierfür nicht die dogmatische Figur der Schutzpflicht heranzieht, hängt auch mit selbstauferlegten Zwängen des Gerichts zusammen. Dabei äußert sich im Klimabeschluss zugleich ein tieferliegendes Problem der Maßstabsbildung durch das Bundesverfassungsgericht. Continue reading >>Solidarität statt Social Distancing
Mit dem Vertrag von Lissabon hat das Ziel einer sozialen Marktwirtschaft Eingang in die EU-Verträge gefunden. Dennoch war das letzte Jahrzehnt von primär wirtschaftspolitischen Integrationsbestrebungen dominiert; der Ausbau der sozialen Dimension der Union ist hingegen fragmentarisch geblieben. Die Europäische Säule Sozialer Rechte soll nun eine Trendwende einleiten. Bei dem Sozialgipfel in Porto am 7. und 8. Mai steht die Realisierung des „sozialen Europas“ ganz oben auf der Agenda. Continue reading >>The State Advances, the People Retreat
It is widely agreed that Wuhan, China is the origin of this pandemic. China has also been criticized for its initial mishandling of the outbreak, including local officials’ cover-up, the incompetence of the Chinese Centre for Disease Control (CDC), and the repression of whistle-blowers. In light of what had happened in other countries, however, China’s subsequent responses were nothing short of miraculous. From its lockdown in Wuhan, to the nationwide joint prevention and control system, from border sealing to mass testing and contact tracing, China’s measures were more intense than almost anywhere else in the world. Continue reading >>
0
03 May 2021
I am the State
The final report of the European Commission dealing with its decision on the European subsidies for the companies associated with the Agrofert holding owned by the Czech Prime Minister has been published on 23 April. Babiš' strong reaction not only reveals something about the ongoing conflict of interest, but also about his neo-patrimonial ruling in general. It is clear that Babiš does not distinguish between public and private positions – he treats public property in the same way an entrepreneur treats private property. Continue reading >>
0
Das ist Alles von der Kunstfreiheit gedeckt
Ein Ende März veröffentlichter Song des Rappers Danger Dan und eine darauf bezogene schriftliche Anfrage des Bundestagsabgeorndeten Frank Pasemann aktualisieren das Thema „Kulturkampf von Rechts“ im Kontext der staatlichen Kulturförderung. Die AfD verfolgt nämlich eine gefährliche Strategie, die nicht nur die geförderten Künstler:innen sondern auch die staatliche Kulturförderung systematisch diskreditieren soll. Continue reading >>01 May 2021
Democracy and the Global Pandemic
What’s the future of the free world? What does the ‘free world’ even mean? Recent reports from leading democracy assessment bodies depict a shrinking democratic atlas that is more fragmented than it has been for decades after a steep decline in every world region. Continue reading >>
0
30 April 2021
Judges for Future
The judgment of 29 April 2021 quashing parts of the Climate Protection Act (CPA) has made history. Not only because the First Senate of the BVerfG put an end to deferring the reduction of greenhouse gasses to the future, or at least to the next government. But because this turn to the future came in the form of a turn to international law and institutions. It is precisely by relying on international law that the court overcomes the counter-majoritarian difficulty commonly tantalizing climate litigation and human rights law generally. The most astonishing fact is, however, that the court entirely avoids the tragic choice between supposedly undemocratic international commitments and the democratic legislature. I argue that it does so by approaching constitutional law in a decidedly postcolonial perspective. Continue reading >>Die Freiheit der Zukunft
Der Klima-Beschluss des Bundesverfassungsgerichts schlägt hohe Wellen. National wie international wird das Urteil bereits jetzt als Meilenstein für den Klimaschutz gefeiert. Der Beschluss legt den Grundstein für eine weitergehende und dauerhafte verfassungsgerichtliche Kontrolle der staatlichen Klimaschutzbemühungen anhand der Grundrechte und Art. 20a GG Continue reading >>Einheit bis zum Bruch
Mit gesteigerter Intensität versucht die Union in diesen Monaten, endlich einen seit Jahren verhandelten Vertrag zum Abschluss zu bringen, der die Assoziation der Schweiz an die Rechtsordnung der Union in einen institutionellen Rahmen stellen soll. Die angestrebte Dynamisierung und Institutionalisierung würde einen bedeutenden Integrationsschritt und eine wichtige Weichenstellung in den Beziehungen der Schweiz und der Union darstellen. Das Projekt berührt aber auch grundsätzliche Fragen der Situierung der Union in einem weiteren europäischen Horizont und gewinnt darin zusätzliche Brisanz. Continue reading >>
0
29 April 2021
The Constitution Speaks in the Future Tense
Who ought to decide on climate issues? Now, the Constitutional Court has decided. It held that the provisions of the Federal Climate Protection Act are “incompatible with fundamental rights insofar as they lack sufficient specifications for further emission reductions from 2031 onwards”. This decision is extraordinary in many ways: in its interpretation of the constitutional obligation to protect the environment (art. 20a of the Basic Law) as much as in its commitment to international cooperation and international law in climate issues. From this decision on, the German constitution will speak in the future tense. Continue reading >>Between European Commitment and ‘Taking the Law Seriously’
On 27 April 2021, the Constitutional Law Committee of the Finnish Parliament adopted its much-awaited opinion on the EU’s Own Resources Decision. It established that its approval requires a qualified majority and thus a significant bulk of votes from the opposition, which has been highly critical of the package. Now, for many MPs, the situation creates an impossible dilemma between their European commitment and taking the law seriously. Continue reading >>
0
After Orbán
With a view to the 2022 elections, there is a serious contradiction in Hungarian public opinion: There should be a regime change away from Orbán's Fidesz, but the Basic Law, which they have undermined and weaponized, should not be touched. This will not work. In any case, it is necessary to get rid of the present Hungarian constitution. Continue reading >>Wo kein Normkonflikt, da kein Kompetenzkonflikt
Schon im Vorfeld des Entscheides des Bundesverfassungsgerichtes zum Mietendeckel vom 15. April ist darauf hingewiesen worden, dass dieser die Verzahnung von föderaler Kompetenzordnung und Tragweite des Grundrechtsschutzes offenlegen werde. Noch deutlicher wird diese Verzahnung im Vergleich mit einem höchstrichterlichen Verdikt zur Verfassungsmässigkeit einer kommunalen Volksinitiative zur Bremsung der Mietpreise in der Stadt Bern vom November 2019. Continue reading >>COVID-19 in Kenya a Year Later: A Case of Déjà Vu
What began as a health crisis quickly morphed into an economic, human rights and governance upheaval. In March 2021, we came full circle as we saw a return to excessive law enforcement in the country on account of the third wave of the virus, which has led to a surge in the number of people testing positive and thrown the country back into a state of disarray as poorly resourced health facilities grapple with the influx of cases. Continue reading >>28 April 2021
Migrant Workers’ Safety Concerns Should be a Pandemic Priority
In the second year of the pandemic, migrant workers continue to work under precarious conditions, exacerbated by the additional risks associated with Covid-19. Social security assistance in Germany, including health care provisions, requires a minimum of 70 working days before employers are required to contribute. During last year’s agricultural season, the German government raised this minimum to 115 days. This made healthcare the responsibility of one’s country of citizenship, not of one’s employer. This year, in April 2021, the German farming industry has successfully pressured the government to re-extend this provision to 102 days. Continue reading >>
0
Wie europäisch wird deutsches Polizeirecht?
Das europäische Polizeirecht befindet sich inmitten eines Paradigmenwechsels. Während das Europarecht zunächst noch primär auf Polizeikooperation ausgerichtet war, lässt sich inzwischen eine zunehmende Vereinheitlichung des mitgliedstaatlichen Sicherheitsrechts beobachten. Nicht nur für den Grundrechtsschutz hat diese Entwicklung weitreichende Folgen. Auch auf politischer Ebene ist mit Gegenwind der Mitgliedstaaten gegenüber der fortschreitenden Harmonierung des innerstaatlichen Sicherheitsrechts zu rechnen. Continue reading >>The COVID-19 Crisis in Latvia
The government response to COVID-19 in Latvia can be characterised as one of legal caution. Even though successive states of emergency have been used to manage the crisis, adequate parliamentary and judicial oversight has resulted in broadly proportional handling of the pandemic. Continue reading >>
0
Solving the Copenhagen Dilemma
By proclaiming an entirely new ‘non-regression’ principle in EU law based on the connection between Articles 49 TEU (EU Enlargement) and 2 TEU (EU values, referred to from Art. 49), the Court of Justice achieved huge progress in addressing a well-known lacuna undermining the EU legal order. The ‘non-regression’ principle is a new important direction in the notable fight for the EU rule of law started with the discovery of EU competence in, in particular, the area of judicial independence and the organization of the judiciaries in the EU Member States. Continue reading >>
0
How the EU is Becoming a Rule-of-Law-less Union of States
The most recent attempt by Poland's executive to undermine the very foundations of the Union legal order speaks volumes about how far the politics of resentment have come since 2015. With the Constitutional Tribunal about to hand the government its desired excuse to ignore interim measures of the Court of Justice of the European Union, a point of no return might have been reached. This new phase sees the dismantling of the rule of law on the domestic front being reinforced, aided and abetted now by the legitimizing inaction and/or spineless bargaining at … the supranational level. The EU through its institutions is playing the game according to the rules dictated by the smart autocrats. Continue reading >>27 April 2021
Ireland cannot do it alone
Due diligence obligations for online platforms are probably the most relevant aspect of the European Commission’s proposal for a Digital Services Act (DSA). However, the DSA's proposed oversight structure is based on the country of origin approach, which has proven difficult in the past. An alternative oversight model which would allow for all Member States, especially the ones who are willing and capable to spend resources to contribute to the oversight over very large platforms, is preferable. Continue reading >>
0
Infektionsschutzmaßnahmen in der Schnittmenge von Verwaltungsanordnung und Gesetzesbefehl
Dem rechtswissenschaftlichen Beobachter bietet sich bei infektionsschutzrechtlichen Maßnahmen mittlerweile das Bild einer völligen Austauschbarkeit der Handlungsformen Verwaltungsakt (Allgemeinverfügung), Rechtsverordnung und Parlamentsgesetz. Anordnungen, die als (konkret-generelle) Einzelfallregelungen beurteilt werden, wenn sie in einer Allgemeinverfügung stehen, finden sich inhaltlich identisch in Rechtsverordnungen und nunmehr auch im IfSG. Trotzdem liegt mit § 28b IfSG weder ein unzulässiger Übergriff des Bundesgesetzgebers in reservierte Exekutiv- oder Länderkompetenzen noch ein unzulässiges Einzelfallgesetz vor. Continue reading >>
0
A Relieving Decision
With its interim decision of 15 April 2021, the German Federal Constitutional Court has paved the way for ratification of the 2020 Own Resources Decision by the German side. At the same time, the Court shows that it will apply the well-known constitutional standards in the main proceedings, possibly – this is only a guess – concentrated on the ultra vires review, which allows the all-important dialogue with the ECJ to continue in the framework of a preliminary ruling procedure. Continue reading >>
0
COVID-19 and the Rule of Law in Croatia: Majoritarian or Constitutional Democracy?
The Croatian government has, much like any other, struggled to find an adequate response to the pandemic of COVID-19. “Dancing with the virus” for the last year entailed introducing, relaxing and re-introducing more or less stringent measures limiting constitutional rights and individual liberties based on epidemiologic developments and political priorities of the day, or season. The measures have ranged from almost a full lockdown in early 2020 when our numbers of infections were amongst the lowest ones in Europe, to a (far too) lenient regime during the tourist season in summer and fall 2020, when the budgetary, economic and political concerns prevailed over the need to address the serious worsening of our epidemiologic parameters. Even today, in the midst of the ‘third wave’, Croatia has quite a moderate set of measures. Continue reading >>
0
Bad Tandem
With its ruling of 15 April 2021, the Polish Constitutional Tribunal willingly accepts the role of substitute lawmaker. The result is an inelegant, clumsy judgment that creates more problems than it solves. The Constitutional Court as the executor of the parliamentary majority destroys not only its reputation but also the purpose of the negative legislator. In the case of the Commissioner for Human Rights, the solution of a political problem is once again transferred to the Constitutional Court. Continue reading >>
0
26 April 2021
Fußball, Kartelle und Recht
Das „Super League“-Intermezzo hat den Finger in die Wunde des Spitzenfußballs gelegt. Die Rechtfertigung der bestehenden Strukturen leidet unter der zunehmenden Unfähigkeit, die Topteams in einem Wettbewerb zu halten, der diesen Namen auf nationaler Ebene und im Ligaalltag verdient. Das europäische Kartellrecht steht und stand den Verantwortlichen nicht im Wege, um Europa vor einer „Super League“ und bestehenden Oligopolen zu bewahren und dabei den breiten Wettbewerb zu fördern. Continue reading >>
0