Jakob Hohnerlein

Restrisiken der Kultur

Das Bundesverfassungsgericht hat am 20. Mai 2021 eine Verfassungsbeschwerde prominenter Musiker:innen gegen die "Bundesnotbremse" nicht zur Entscheidung angenommen. Der Beschluss ist eine verpasste Chance, denn die Kammer wagt es nicht, von der Politik einzufordern, künstlerische Entfaltung (jenseits digitaler Formate) auch unter Pandemiebedingungen bei Anwendung umfassender Schutzkonzepte zu ermöglichen. Continue reading >>

Karl-E. Hain

Thieves in the temple?

In ihrem Programmentwurf zur Bundestagswahl mahnt die FDP eine Reform des öffentlich-rechtlichen Rundfunks an. Die erwartbaren Immun(-isierungs-)reak­tionen, die sie damit hervorgerufen hat, verengen dabei den notwendigen Diskurs über Auftrag und Struktur des öffentlich-rechtlichen Rundfunks. Reformen sind nicht verfassungswidrig, solange sie die verfassungsrechtlichen Rahmen für den Funktionsauftrag und die Programmautonomie der Anstalten beachten. Die Transformation ins Digitale darf den öffentlich-rechtlichen Rundfunk nicht in eine digitale Nische führen. Continue reading >>

Christian Calliess

„Elfes“ Revisited?

So überzeugend der Klimabeschluss des BVerfG im Hinblick auf die strukturelle Koppelung der planetaren Grenzen in Form des 1,5-2 Grad-Ziels mit Art. 20a GG im Ergebnis ist, so sehr wirft doch der grundrechtliche Weg dahin in rechtsdogmatischer Hinsicht viele Fragen auf. Ich konzentriere mich in diesem Beitrag auf die Frage, ob der Erste Senat die berühmte, aber zugleich auch umstrittene „Elfes“-Konstruktion fruchtbar macht und in diesem Rahmen einen im Hinblick auf die Grundrechtsdogmatik tragfähigen und zukunftsweisenden Weg beschritten hat. Continue reading >>

Alexander Hobusch

Digitaler Fortschritt, parteienrechtlicher Rückschritt

Es war die Pandemie, die die Parteien dazu getrieben hat, ihre Parteitage ins Internet zu verlegen. Warum, so könnte man sich fragen, die innerparteiliche Willensbildung nicht generell auf digitale Kanäle verlegen? Hat dieser Notbehelf nicht eigentlich gut geklappt? Der wegweisende CDU-Parteitag, lange verschoben, wurde online durchgeführt, die weit weniger hitzigen Versammlungen von SPD und FDP zuletzt ebenfalls. Doch was modern und neuartig klingt, ist bei genauerer Betrachtung nicht zwingend ein Fortschritt für die innerparteiliche Demokratie. Continue reading >>

Shunyu Chi

Alibaba: Punishment and Collaboration

On 6 April 2021, Alibaba, a leading e-commerce platform, was fined $2.75 billion for abuse of dominance in the Chinese market. In the weeks that followed, Chinese regulators started investigations into other giants of the platform economy, for similar anti-competitive conduct. They signify a shift in Chinese regulators’ strong determination to crack down on monopolistic conduct. Continue reading >>

Yaniv Roznai

The Basic Structure Doctrine arrives in Kenya

On 13 May 2021, a panel of five High Court justices ruled that the so-called Basic Structure Doctrine applies in Kenya. The judgment is not only a milestone from the perspective of comparative constitutional law; it might also change the future landscape of constitutionalism in Africa. Continue reading >>

Armin Steinbach

Administrierte Freiheitschancen

Klimaneutralität als alternativloses Ziel politischen Handelns hat jetzt das höchstrichterliche Plazet. Zugleich befördert die neue intergenerationale Vorwirkungsdogmatik einen klimapolitischen Unilateralismus, der so manche ökonomische Binsenweisheit in den Wind schlägt: Trittbrettfahren und carbon leakage werden bei unilateralem Vorpreschen noch für klimapolitische Ernüchterung sorgen. Continue reading >>

Marten Breuer

Die Freiheit der Anderen

Der Beschluss des Bundesverfassungsgerichts zum Klimaschutz ist ein rechtspolitisch wichtiges Signal, auf das die Politik umgehend reagiert hat. Doch so wünschenswert es aus rechtspolitischer Sicht auch sein mag, so unklar sind die grundrechtsdogmatischen Implikationen. Hierzu einige – eher skizzenhafte – Überlegungen. Continue reading >>

Aytekin Kaan Kurtul

A Ghost that Haunts European Democracies

In Turkey, Spain and Poland, lèse-majesté laws are weaponised against opposition: The conviction and imprisonment of Marxist rapper Pablo Hasél sparked mass protests across Spain, and the 20-year-old Wiktoria K. who shouted “f*** Duda” during last year’s demonstrations and received a guilty verdict on grounds of “insulting the President” in March 2021. The very existence of lèse-majesté laws poses a threat to the right to dissent. It is a vital democratic duty to cast such laws into the dustbin of history. Continue reading >>

Edina Harbinja

The UK’s Online Safety Bill: Safe, Harmful, Unworkable?

On 12 May 2021, the UK Government published the long-awaited Online Safety Bill. While the UK Government aims to show “global leadership with our groundbreaking laws to usher in a new age of accountability for tech and bring fairness and accountability to the online world”, this claim is more than doubtful. Continue reading >>

Lukas Märtin, Carl Mühlbach

Generationengerechtigkeit und Fiskalpolitik

In seinem Beschluss zum Klimaschutzgesetz hat das BVerfG nicht nur den Klimaschutz gestärkt, sondern auch ein anderes Prinzip aus Art. 20a GG betont: die Generationengerechtigkeit. Bisher gelten in Deutschland oftmals Schuldenbremse und schwarze Null als generationengerechtes Optimum. Diese Ausrichtung ist jedoch das genaue Gegenteil einer Generationengerechtigkeit, wie sie nun auch das BVerfG auslegt. Continue reading >>

Daniel Thym

Menschenrechtliche Grenzen für Pushbacks – und der weitergehende Schutz nach EU-Sekundärrecht

Das europäische Asylrecht plagen mehrere Strukturprobleme. Es setzt auf hochkomplizierte Verfahren, die in langen Verordnungen niedergelegt sind, die an den europäischen Außengrenzen rechtspraktisch vielfach nicht funktionieren. Außerdem gibt es bis zum heutigen Tag keine einzige Vorlage eines griechischen Gerichts, die sich mit der Situation auf den griechischen Inseln oder gar mit der Grenzüberwachung in der Ägäis beschäftigte. Continue reading >>

Joaquín Urías

The Right of Catalonian Leaders to Protest

On 22 April, the Spanish Constitutional Court issued its first judgement on the constitutionality of the conviction of the Catalonian leaders for the events of October 2017. It upheld the Supreme Court’s interpretation of the crime of sedition which blurs the line between legitimate protest and sedition. The judgment will therefore have repercussions beyond this particular case and may affect the right of protest and dissent. Continue reading >>

Kelly Shuttleworth

Fast-tracking Scotland’s re-entry to the EU

As the dust settles with a pro-independence - though not an SNP - majority in the Scottish Parliament after the May 2021 elections, it is worth considering what an independent Scotland’s (accelerated) path back to the EU could look like. Increasing the speed at which an independent Scotland could rejoin the EU is primarily an issue of political will and domestic preparation. Continue reading >>

Joelle Grogan

Power, Law and the COVID-19 Pandemic – Part I: The Year of Pandemic

Involving over 100 contributors worldwide, the 2021 Power and COVID-19 Pandemic series builds on the 2020 COVID-19 and States of Emergency Symposium to again provide snapshot critical analysis of a world in continued crisis and extended emergency. This final commentary in the 2021 Symposium is divided in two parts: first, an analysis of the impact the pandemic has had on legal systems over the course of the last year; and second, an outlook on how to prepare for future emergencies by building on the lessons of the current one. This is part I. Continue reading >>

John Philipp Thurn

Schweigen als Sozialisierungssperre?

Am 10. Mai 2021 wurde der Entwurf für ein Vergesellschaftungsgesetz vorgestellt, mit dem eine Berliner Kampagne nach einem erfolgreichen Volksentscheid am 26. September 2021 die Wohnungen großer Immobilienunternehmen in Gemeineigentum überführen will. Diese geplante erste Sozialisierung im Sinne von Art. 15 GG wirft viele Rechtsfragen auf, zu denen es bislang keine Rechtsprechung, sondern vor allem eine Reihe von Gutachten und wenig wissenschaftliche Literatur gibt: Was darf unter welchen Voraussetzungen vergesellschaftet werden, und zu welcher Entschädigung? Continue reading >>

Armin von Bogdandy

Our European Society and Its Conference on the Future of Europe

9 May 2021 saw the official launch of the Conference on the Future of Europe. 70 years of Europeanization have not yielded a European people, the treaty maker is saying, nor – God forbid – created a European federal state. They have, however, given rise to a European society. Continue reading >>

Christine Bell, Sean Molloy, Asanga Welikala, Kimana Zulueta-Fülscher, Erin Houlihan, Rasha Al Saba, Samrawit Gougsa, Joelle Grogan, Sheila Jasanoff, Stephen Hilgartner, Joshua Castellino

WEBINAR 5: “Quo Vadis? – The Impact of an Extended Emergency”

How has COVID-19 impacted upon legal and political systems; minorities and indigenous peoples; and conflict-affected states in transition? This final panel debates themes of trust, equality, conflict and power, and concludes with a commentary by the convenor of the Symposium who will draw together key findings, emergent threats, and reasons for hope. Continue reading >>

Anna Katharina Mangold, Kriszta Kovács, Wen-Chen Chang, Julinda Beqiraj, Shaheera Syed, Nadia Tariq-Ali, Chun-Yuan Lin, Joelle Grogan

WEBINAR 4: “The Rule of Law in the Pandemic”

The COVID-19 pandemic has placed extreme strain on legal systems, requiring action in response to fast-changing and complex situation of the pandemic emergency. This panel evaluates state action - and in particular, executive-decision making - in response to the pandemic against the standard of the rule of law, and considers whether this will lead to permanent shifts in legal systems worldwide. Continue reading >>

Matthias Lehnert

Pushbacks sind illegal – und zwar immer

Mittlerweile kann kaum mehr bestritten werden, dass an den europäischen Außengrenzen Menschen zurückgewiesen werden, ohne ihr Schutzgesuch geltend machen zu können und ohne ein Prüfverfahren gewährleistet zu bekommen. Derweil werden immer mehr Stimmen laut, die nicht allein die Tatsachen, sondern zugleich das Recht und damit in Frage stellen, dass sogenannte Pushbacks den Menschenrechten, dem Völkerrecht und dem Europarecht widersprechen. Gründe genug für eine Klarstellung: Pushbacks sind illegal, und zwar immer. Continue reading >>

Mark A. Graber, Ciara Staunton, Iain Cameron, Anna Jonsson-Cornell, Jerome Amir Singh

WEBINAR 3: “Science, Law and Decision-Making”

Bringing together experts representing states who have adopted divergent attitudes to the role of science in law and decision-making, as well as an examination of vaccination policy, equity and individual choice, this panel considers the complex policy choices, rationales and politics which interplay in decision-making during a pandemic. Continue reading >>

Tom Gerald Daly, Hans Petter Graver, Michael Meyer-Resende, Dean R Knight, Sabine El Hayek

WEBINAR 2: “Democracy and Disruption”

How has democracy been impacted by over a year of pandemic response and emergency? How have states ensured the democratic accountability of their actions in response to the global health emergency? What lessons can be learned for now, and for the future? This panel examines democratic practices, and highlights the best – and most concerning – developments. Continue reading >>

Frank Grootens, Frederik Orlowski

Sie haben ihm ein Denkmal gebaut

In der Woche, in der Frankreich des 200. Todestags Napoleon Bonapartes feierlich gedachte, schaffte auch der Deutsche Bundestag erinnerungspolitische Fakten. Ohne Gegenstimmen bewilligte er ein Gesetz zur Errichtung einer Bundeskanzler-Helmut-Kohl-Stiftung. Doch die vordergründige Einmütigkeit des Plenums täuscht. Continue reading >>

Alice Donald, Nerima Were, Tara Imalingat, Manon Julicher, Max Vetzo, Maria Ela L. Atienza, Lucy Moxham

WEBINAR 1: “Human Rights and the COVID-19 Pandemic”

COVID-19 – and state responses to it - present a threat to human rights unparalleled in the contemporary era. At the same time, human rights offer a universal framework which guides decision-makers, ensures accountability for their actions and omissions, and renders visible the structural inequalities which drives the pandemic’s differential impact on certain communities. Looking forward, this panel discusses how human rights can be used to underpin a just and sustainable post-pandemic recovery. Continue reading >>

Joelle Grogan

Webinar Series: Power and the COVID-19 Pandemic

Marking the conclusion of the "Power and the COVID-19 Pandemic" Symposium, this webinar series brings together contributors from around the world to discuss the impact of the pandemic on law and governance, drawing on five transversal themes: human rights; democracy; the rule of law; science and decision-making; and the impact of an extended emergency. Continue reading >>

Oreste Pollicino, Giovanni De Gregorio, Marco Bassini

Trump’s Indefinite Ban

After months of waiting, the Facebook Oversight Board has upheld Facebook’s ban of former President Donald Trump. Beyond the merits, the decision underlines a trend showing how the FOB is applying protections of free speech. The FOB’s increasing reliance on the principle of proportionality and transparency is a paradigmatic example of an ever-growing distance to the First Amendment dogma characterising US constitutionalism and the proximity to the European (digital) constitutional approach. Continue reading >>

Sheila Jasanoff, Stephen Hilgartner

A Stress Test for Politics: Insights from the Comparative Covid Response Project (CompCoRe) 2020

The CompCoRe study, an ongoing qualitative comparison of policy responses to Covid-19 in sixteen core countries and two affiliates, begun in April 2020, sought to identify and explain patterns of perceived success and failure in managing this multifaceted crisis. [...] As national and international authorities look to futures beyond Covid-19, a lesson emerging from our study is that they should revisit their institutional processes for integrating scientific and political consensus-building. If free citizens are unable to see how expertise is serving the collective good, they will sooner rebel against the experts than give up their independence. Just as a sound mind is said to require a sound body, so the coronavirus has shown that the credibility of public health expertise depends on the health of the body politic. Continue reading >>

Mathieu Leloup

The ECtHR Steps into the Ring

For the last two years, the fight for safeguarding the principle of the rule of law in Poland has been dominated by the ECJ’s case law. During this, the Strasbourg Court has mostly been sitting in the bleachers. Yet, with its Xero Flor judgment of 7 May, it strapped on its gloves and stepped into the ring. It concluded that the Polish Constitutional Tribunal, in its current composition, cannot be seen as a tribunal established by law. The decision will undoubtedly have major political and legal consequences. Continue reading >>

Christina Eckes

Separation of Powers in Climate Cases

On 29 April 2021, the Bundesverfassungsgericht published its decision that the Federal Climate Change Act of 12 December 2019, establishing national climate targets and annual emission amounts allowed until 2030, violates fundamental rights. Do the judges in such a case undermine separation of powers as a time-honoured achievement of modern constitutional democracies in order to force the political branches to take urgently necessary actions? No. By allocating different functions to the three branches, executive, legislature, and judiciary, separation of powers aims to ensure that the tension between law and majoritarian politics is perpetuated and that neither law nor politics dominates the other. Continue reading >>

Jerome Amir Singh

COVID-19 vaccines: How Structural Factors Can Vitiate Patient Autonomy and Dictate Vaccine Choice

Financial self-interest, fiscal considerations, geopolitics, sovereignty, governance, protectionism, and nationalism are currently dictating COVID-19 vaccine procurement at the macro level. Such structural factors indirectly vitiate autonomy at the grassroots level and run counter to the ideal that individuals should have access to the highest attainable standard of health. Continue reading >>

Konrad Lachmayer

Muddling through Mutation Times or the Return of Federalism in Austria

While the Austrian government´s reactions during the first wave of Covid-19 in spring 2020 are considered to have been successful, disillusionment followed in the fall 2020 with a second wave, for which the government did not seem to have prepared properly. The third period (January to April 2021), on which I will focus in this blog entry, shows a mixed performance of the government. Continue reading >>

Bat-Orgil Altankhuyag

The Price of Limiting Power

On 18 April 2021, Mongolia’s political landscape was hit by an unexpected event: President Battulga Khaltmaa issued an official decree in which he suggested to dissolve Mongolia’s 100-year-old ruling party, the Mongolian People’s Party (MPP). What appears to be a political problem at first glance, points to a deeper crisis of Mongolia’s constitutional democracy. Continue reading >>

Hoitismolimo Mutlokwa

A Failed State in the Making

On 4 May 2021, the Senate house in Zimbabwe approved the Constitutional Amendment No.2, 2019 with a two-thirds majority. The bill is now on its way to the executive for signature and incorporation into the constitution. However, the bill features three concerning clauses linked to judicial independence and the prosecutor general's appointment. The future of democracy and the rule of law looks gloomy for Zimbabwe. Continue reading >>